How to deal with golf handicap fudging?

My buddies and I love to play in local scramble golf tournaments. However, we are getting very frustrated with certain groups of golfers who show up for these tournaments and play under handicaps that everyone knows are incorrect, they are waaaaay too high. Almost every time, one of these foursomes wins, and usually one of the others take second. Is there a way to handle this?

One of the things that drives me absolutely nuts (no pun intended) is fudging on golf handicaps. The history and tradition of the game of golf are supposed to mean something, but people abuse the honor system that golf handicapping uses. I mean what the …….wait a minute, I’m sorry, I tend to get carried away.

Back to the question, is there a solution for this? I’m not sure that there is a long term answer. My experience with this, and I have had the EXACT same experience that you describe, is that many times some of these guys are your friends, or at least acquaintances. So that makes it even tougher to say anything. And, usually no one wants to ruin the mood of the tournament by calling them on it.

So what to do? Well I did see this situation handled in a very interesting way one time. And if you have access to the tournament chairman or director (and if he’s sympathetic to your cause) you may want to consider this.

A buddy of mine had had enough and talked to the tournament director of a scramble he was playing in. The director was very supportive and came up with a quick and, what I would call very appropriate, solution. He put all the foursomes of the “known” fudgers in their own flight! Everyone else was flighted accurately and the tournament was a smashing success.

Of course, the “special” flight group was not thrilled, but what were they going to do? Just like everyone else previously, if they said something, it would probably ruin the mood of the tournament and be viewed in bad taste.

Unconventional, but when have I ever given conventional answers? Good luck and good golfing.


Comments

Without doubt some golfers lie about the handicaps they submit for team handicap determinations, but the method used to calculate those team handicaps contributes to the problem. I suggest you go to www.scramblehandicapping.com to see how some popular methodologies give advantages to better golfers and what can be done about it.

Posted by: John Scully at November 21, 2005 02:22 PM

I actually think that these "cheaters" should be called out! I turn in every score and really try to accurately track my golf handicap.

It really makes me mad when these guys show up and take the prizes. I only think that you would have to do it one time and you would get all the support you need from all the golfers in the tournament.

Do it right or don't do it.

John Stryker

Posted by: John Stryker at March 1, 2007 07:38 AM

John,

We probably all feel the same as you do. Nothing can be as frustrating as thinking you have a chance to win and watch it go to a group of golfers that you know shouldn't be in your flight.

Hang in there and enjoy the game of golf! Don't let it ruin your round if you can.

The Golf Nut

Posted by: The Golf Nut at March 1, 2007 07:49 AM

I like your suggestion. But there is another simple solution:

Don't invite them back the next time. In my experience everyone knows who these golfers are and what they are doing.

So thank them for this year and be done with them. If they ask why, tell them.

Mel

Posted by: Mel at July 26, 2007 06:22 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?


Note: All comments are submitted to the site editors for approval before being published.






Assigned to category: Golf Rules and Etiquette
« Best way to practice your golf swing? | Main | Buying New Golf Clubs? »